Watching a Freeze-Drying Cycle: What Temperature and Pressure Sensors Reveal
A freeze-drying cycle is long and mostly invisible. The chamber is closed, the shelves are cold, and the water in each container leaves as vapour over many hours. Monitoring is the only way to know what is actually happening inside the cake while it happens — rather than inferring it afterwards from the dried powder.
Two measurements carry most of the load: the temperature of the product, and the pressure in the chamber. A review of monitoring methods for freeze-drying groups the available systems into three families — those based on temperature measurement, those based on chamber pressure measurement (pressure rise and pressure decrease tests), and those based on estimating the sublimation flux, such as tunable diode laser absorption spectroscopy and valveless monitoring systems [5].
Why product temperature is the first thing measured
Product temperature is one of the methods adopted to monitor the freeze-drying process and to obtain the values of the process parameters needed by mathematical models for in-line or off-line optimisation [2]. In other words, the probe is not only a thermometer. Fed into a model of the process, the temperature trace yields quantities that cannot be measured directly.
Work published in Pharmaceutics investigated direct temperature measurement to determine not just the product temperature but also the end of primary drying and the process parameters — the heat and mass transfer coefficients — while evaluating how uncertain those results are [2]. Primary drying is the long stage in which frozen water leaves the cake as vapour; knowing when it ends matters because holding the cycle longer than necessary wastes hours, and ending it early leaves ice behind.
The experiments used thin thermocouples in a lab-scale freeze-dryer with two model solutions: sucrose and PVP [2]. The authors chose them because they represent two different kinds of dried structure. One type has a structure strongly non-uniform in the axial direction, with pore size varying through the depth of the cake and a crust at the surface, which makes the cake's resistance to vapour flow strongly non-linear [2]. The other has a uniform, open structure, where cake resistance varies linearly with thickness [2]. The same instrument therefore has to cope with two very different internal geometries.
The results confirmed that model parameters in both cases can be estimated with an uncertainty in agreement with that obtained using other, more invasive and more expensive sensors [2]. The paper also discussed the strengths and weaknesses of the thermocouple approach, comparing it with a contactless device — an infrared camera [2]. Either a contact or a contactless device, combined with a simple algorithm based on a mathematical model of the process, can be used as a monitoring tool [2].
Measuring at several heights at once
A single probe reads one point. A cake dries from the top down, so one point tells you about one layer. A study in Frontiers in Chemistry describes a fully wireless, multi-point temperature sensor system in which each sensor contains seven sensing elements measuring product temperature at various positions within the contents of a glass vial [6].
The sensors were tested in freeze-drying runs with placement at both the centre and the edge of a full shelf, using 6R glass vials with a 4 ml fill volume [6]. The product temperature profile and the primary drying time measured at the bottom-centre position compared closely with thermocouple data [6].
The useful part is what multiple heights reveal. Drying times were determined at top, higher middle, lower middle and bottom positions, spaced 3.26 mm apart vertically in the vial [6]. For a centre vial, the time from the start of primary drying to each layer was 3.9, 9.3, 14.2 and 21 hours respectively — which let the authors track the sublimation interface as it moved down through the cake [6].
From those times, the sublimation rate at each layer was calculated using the theoretical weight loss of ice in the product [6]. The rate at the beginning of primary drying was similar to the rate obtained by the gravimetric method, that is, by weighing [6]. The vial heat transfer coefficient was then calculated from the sublimation rate [6]. The authors note this allows the sublimation rate and heat transfer coefficient to be monitored rapidly for every batch as continuous process verification [6]. Similar tests with 3% w/v mannitol solutions gave consistent results, which the authors present as demonstrating potential for real-time monitoring, process verification and cycle optimisation [6].
What chamber pressure adds
Temperature probes sit in a few containers. Chamber pressure is a property of the whole batch. The pressure-based family of methods uses tests of pressure rise and of pressure decrease [5]. Alongside flux-based systems, these approaches have been applied to in-line process optimisation — for example with a model predictive control algorithm — and to off-line calculation of the design space of the process [5]. Design space here means the range of operating conditions identified in advance as acceptable, rather than settings found by trial during production.
Measuring what came out
Monitoring the cycle is one half; characterising the resulting powder is the other. One study of cellulose-encapsulated material found a "flake-like" structure in the powder that differed significantly from the emulsified microcapsules it came from, while useful properties were retained [1].
Porosity is a common target of this analysis. Materials prepared with a porogen and subjected to lyophilisation showed well-developed surfaces featuring macropores and cavities, characterised by electron microscopy, infrared spectroscopy, thermogravimetric analysis, differential scanning calorimetry and X-ray diffraction, and supported by open porosity measurements [3]. For dried extracts, UV-VIS diffuse reflectance spectroscopy, FTIR, near-infrared spectroscopy and thermogravimetric analysis have been used to characterise freeze-dried plant extracts prepared in water, water-methanol and water-ethanol solvents [7]. Near-infrared spectra of freeze-dried and ground samples have also been collected across four different optical systems — a laboratory spectrometer, a transportable spectrometer in two configurations, and a micro-spectrometer — to allow comparison between instruments [8].
What a brand can take from this
When agreeing how a freeze-dried powder will be made, it is worth asking what was measured during the cycle, not only what the finished cake looks like. A temperature trace that identifies the end of primary drying gives a defensible reason for the cycle length [2]. And the dried powder itself can be described in concrete terms — structure under electron microscopy, composition by infrared spectroscopy, thermal behaviour by thermogravimetric analysis [1]. Each of those is a number or an image that can be compared from one batch to the next.
References
- Shlosman K, Rein DM, Shemesh R, Cohen Y. Lyophilized Emulsions of Thymol and Eugenol Essential Oils Encapsulated in Cellulose — Polymers, 2024-05-17.
- Vallan A, Fissore D, Pisano R, Barresi AA. On the Use of Temperature Measurements as a Process Analytical Technology (PAT) for the Monitoring of a Pharmaceutical Freeze-Drying Process — Pharmaceutics, 2023-03-07.
- Lavlinskaya MS, Sorokin AV. Enhancement of Water Uptake in Composite Superabsorbents Based on Carboxymethyl Cellulose Through Porogen Incorporation and Lyophilization — Gels (Basel, Switzerland), 2024-12-05.
- Vishweshwaran M, Sujatha ER, Baldovino JA. Freeze-Dried β-Glucan and Poly-γ-glutamic Acid: An Efficient Stabilizer to Strengthen Subgrades of Low Compressible Fine-Grained Soils with Varying Curing Periods — Polymers, 2024-06-03.
- Fissore D. Model-Based PAT for Quality Management in Pharmaceuticals Freeze-Drying: State of the Art — Frontiers in bioengineering and biotechnology, 2017-02-07.
- Jiang X, Zhu T, Kodama T, Raghunathan N, Alexeenko A, Peroulis D. Multi-Point Wireless Temperature Sensing System for Monitoring Pharmaceutical Lyophilization — Frontiers in chemistry, 2018-07-17.
- Aleksieiev A, Masłowski M, Efenberger-Szmechtyk M, Strzelec K. The Influence of Freeze-Dried Alcohol-Water Extracts from Common Yarrow ( Achillea millefolium L.) and German Chamomile ( Matricaria chamomilla L.) on the Properties of Elastomer Vulcanizates — International journal of molecular sciences, 2022-11-30.
- Pérémé M, Mallet A, Awhangbo L, Charnier C, Roger JM, Steyer JP, Latrille É, Bendoula R. On-site substrate characterization in the anaerobic digestion context: A dataset of near infrared spectra acquired with four different optical systems on freeze-dried and ground organic waste — Data in brief, 2021-05-11.