What an Infrared Camera Sees Inside a Freeze-Dryer That Probes Miss
A freeze-drying cycle is run blind unless something measures it. The machine is a sealed, cold, low-pressure box; inside it, water in a liquid formulation is first frozen solid and then removed as vapour. The operator sets a shelf temperature and a chamber pressure, and what the material actually experiences follows from those settings — but not uniformly, and not always as expected. Measuring the cycle is how a factory knows whether every unit in a batch went through the same process.
Two numbers are set and watched: temperature and pressure. In one published freeze-drying procedure, the process was carried out at a temperature of −30 °C and a pressure of 0.37 mbar [6]. Those two figures define the condition under which frozen water leaves the material as vapour rather than melting. They are the headline settings on any cycle record.
How product temperature is normally measured
Product temperature is normally measured using a few invasive Pt-100 probes, which gives poor spatial resolution [5]. "Invasive" means the sensor is placed into the material itself; "poor spatial resolution" means you learn the temperature at a handful of spots and nothing about everywhere else. A probe sitting in one container tells you about that container. It does not tell you about the one at the other end of the shelf.
That limitation matters because freeze-dryers are not uniform. A team coupled an infrared camera to a process-scale freeze dryer for on-line monitoring of freeze-drying cycles, reported as the first time this had been described [5]. The camera looked into the chamber through a germanium window and took an image every 120 seconds, giving 30,000 measurement points obtained contact-free over a range from −40 °C to 25 °C [5]. Contact-free means nothing is inserted into the material, so the measurement does not disturb what it is measuring.
What the images showed
The results are worth stating plainly, because they describe how much a cycle can vary across a single shelf.
- During freezing of the empty system, differences of more than 5 °C were measured on the shelf [5].
- Adding a tray to the empty system produced a difference of more than 8 °C [5].
- In bulk mode during sublimation, a temperature difference of a maximum of 13 °C was observed [5].
- When drying in vials, differences of more than 10 °C were observed [5].
There is a reassuring half of the finding as well. The large temperature differences gradually disappeared during secondary drying, and the products were transformed into uniformly dry cakes [5]. Secondary drying is the later stage of the cycle, after the bulk of the ice has gone, when remaining water is driven off. The spread that dominates freezing and sublimation does not necessarily survive to the end of the run — but you only know that if something was watching.
The same work ran the camera on three different situations: an empty system, bulk drying of a slurry, and drying of 1 mL fills in 150 vials [5]. The conclusion drawn was that the infrared camera is a highly versatile on-line monitoring tool for different kinds of freeze-drying processes [5].
Measuring the result, not just the cycle
Thermal methods are the ones that speak most directly to temperature. Differential thermal analysis of a freeze-dried solid dispersion showed a decrease in melting point compared with the starting material [3]. Differential scanning calorimetry on freeze-dried mixtures showed a decreased melting endotherm and an increased enthalpy change [2]. In another study, thermogravimetric analysis — which tracks weight as a sample is heated — recorded mass losses between 250 °C and 640 °C corresponding to organic material and water, and two temperature transitions were identified at 45.67 °C and 91.89 °C [8]. Thermal stability of freeze-dried plant extracts has likewise been assessed by thermogravimetric analysis [1].
Structure measurements complete the picture. X-ray diffraction of freeze-dried mixtures showed reduced peak intensities relative to the fully crystalline starting material [2], and in another study the diffractogram showed a decrease in peak intensity indicating that the crystalline form had altered to an amorphous phase [3]. Scanning electron microscopy of those freeze-dried mixtures showed a glassy appearance, size reduction and embedment [2]. Pore size in a lyophilised solid has been measured directly from electron micrographs, with a mean of 316 μm at 50× magnification ranging from 91.2 to 497.8 μm [8].
Infrared spectroscopy appears throughout as the routine check on whether anything in the formulation changed. Infrared monitoring has also been performed in situ, during gas exchange and over a wide temperature range, on lyophilised material [4].
What a brand can take from this
When you ask how a freeze-dried powder will be made, ask two things about the cycle rather than one. First, what temperature and pressure the cycle runs at — those are the two settings that define it [6]. Second, how many points in the chamber are actually measured.
Then ask what was measured on the finished cake. Thermal analysis, X-ray diffraction, electron microscopy and infrared spectroscopy are the standard set [2][3], and together they describe whether the dried solid is crystalline or amorphous, how it is structured, and whether its chemistry shifted during the run [2][3][6]. Cycle data and cake data answer different questions. A specification that includes both is harder to argue with than one that includes either alone.
References
- Masłowski M, Aleksieiev A, Miedzianowska J, Efenberger-Szmechtyk M, Strzelec K. Antioxidant and Anti-Aging Activity of Freeze-Dried Alcohol-Water Extracts from Common Nettle ( Urtica dioica L.) and Peppermint ( Mentha piperita L.) in Elastomer Vulcanizates — Polymers, 2022-04-03.
- Ansari MT, Hussain A, Nadeem S, Majeed H, Saeed-Ul-Hassan S, Tariq I, Mahmood Q, Khan AK, Murtaza G. Preparation and Characterization of Solid Dispersions of Artemether by Freeze-Dried Method — BioMed research international, 2015-05-17.
- Fitriani L, Haqi A, Zaini E. Preparation and characterization of solid dispersion freeze-dried efavirenz - polyvinylpyrrolidone K-30 — Journal of advanced pharmaceutical technology & research, 2016-07-01.
- Lorent C, Pelmenschikov V, Frielingsdorf S, Schoknecht J, Caserta G, Yoda Y, Wang H, Tamasaku K, Lenz O, Cramer SP, Horch M, Lauterbach L, Zebger I. Exploring Structure and Function of Redox Intermediates in [NiFe]-Hydrogenases by an Advanced Experimental Approach for Solvated, Lyophilized and Crystallized Metalloenzymes — Angewandte Chemie (International ed. in English), 2021-05-05.
- Emteborg H, Zeleny R, Charoud-Got J, Martos G, Lüddeke J, Schellin H, Teipel K. Infrared thermography for monitoring of freeze-drying processes: instrumental developments and preliminary results — Journal of pharmaceutical sciences, 2014-06-05.
- Pilch E, Musiał W. Selected Physicochemical Properties of Lyophilized Hydrogel with Liposomal Fraction of Calcium Dobesilate — Materials (Basel, Switzerland), 2018-10-31.
- Bordignon JCS, Badaró AT, Barbin DF, Mariutti LRB, Netto FM. Oxidation of whey protein isolate after thermal convection and microwave heating and freeze-drying: Correlation among physicochemical and NIR spectroscopy analyses — Heliyon, 2023-07-06.
- Galia CR, Lourenço AL, Rosito R, Souza Macedo CA, Camargo LM. PHYSICOCHEMICAL CHARACTERIZATION OF LYOPHILIZED BOVINE BONE GRAFTS — Revista brasileira de ortopedia, 2011-07-01.