Freezing in the Vial: How the Ice Forms and Why It Shapes the Dry Cake
Freeze-drying removes water from a liquid by freezing it first and then taking the ice away as vapour. Everything that happens after the freezing step is shaped by the ice that formed during it. The freezing stage governs several critical parameters of the freeze-drying process and the quality of the resulting lyophilised products [7]. Freezing is described as a crucial phase, because it determines both cycle efficiency and product quality [4].
That is the short version of why this one step deserves attention. The ice crystals are, in effect, a mould. When they turn to vapour they leave behind empty channels, and those channels are the pores of the finished dry cake. A brand choosing how its serum or powder is made is, whether it knows it or not, choosing an ice structure.
What the ice leaves behind
The clearest evidence comes from work that looked directly at pore structure after drying. A study of spin freezing examined the relation between freezing and pore size, pore shape, dried-product mass-transfer resistance and the solid state of the dried layer, using high-resolution X-ray micro-computed tomography, scanning electron microscopy, thermal imaging and X-ray diffraction [3]. Mass-transfer resistance is simply how hard it is for water vapour to escape through the already-dried material above.
The finding was a direct trade-off with freezing speed. Slow spin-freezing rates produced highly tortuous structures with a high dried-product mass-transfer resistance [3]. Fast spin-freezing rates produced lamellar structures — layered, sheet-like — with a low tortuosity and a low dried-product mass-transfer resistance [3]. Tortuosity describes how twisting the path through the cake is. A twisted path slows the vapour down; a straight one lets it out.
The same relationship appears in materials made by freezing and then drying. Hydrogels made from silk fibroin were either frozen at -20 °C for 24 hours before drying, or held at 8 °C for 24 hours before drying [2]. X-ray diffraction and infrared measurements indicated that the dialysis time and the freezing did not alter the material's crystallinity, conformation or thermal behaviour [2]. The microstructure, however, was strongly affected: electron micrographs showed porous structures, and the hydrogels that had been frozen presented a much larger pore size [2]. In other words, the freezing step changed the architecture without changing the chemistry.
Freezing can also be made directional, so the ice grows along one axis. Composite aerogels with ordered lamellar structures were fabricated by directional freeze-drying, and the directional process is what generated the ordered lamellar architecture [8]. The same technique that produces a loose, even cake can produce a deliberately layered one, depending on how the cold is applied.
Where the cold comes from matters
Ice grows away from where heat leaves. That makes the container part of the recipe. Gelatin sponges were frozen in three types of mould: a silicon tube with high gas permeability; the same tube covered on the lateral side with a low-gas-permeability film; and the tube covered on both the lateral and bottom sides [5]. The sponge frozen in the high-permeability tube showed a wider pore size and spatial distribution and a larger average pore diameter, 149.2 µm, than those frozen in the covered moulds [5]. The authors concluded that the gas permeability of the moulds critically altered the pore size and spatial pore distribution of the sponges during the freeze-drying process [5]. Nothing about the liquid changed — only what surrounded it.
Cooling speed and fill volume change the timetable as well. Work using an ultrasonic sensor mounted on a stainless steel bottle tracked water freezing in real time; the ultrasonic signals indicated three stages of the freezing process — water-in, the freezing point, and the final phase change of water — and were used to evaluate cooling and freezing periods [7]. Those periods increased with water volume and decreased with shelf temperature, that is, with the speed of freezing [7]. A deeper fill freezes for longer, and a colder shelf shortens the job [7].
Controlling when nucleation happens
Water does not start freezing the moment it is cold enough. Because the first ice crystals appear at unpredictable moments in different containers, techniques have been developed for better control of freezing. One of them, vacuum-induced surface freezing, makes it possible to trigger nucleation at the same time in all the vials being processed [4].
Triggering nucleation deliberately interacts with the vial's inner surface. Hydrophobic coatings promoted boiling and blow-up phenomena, resulting in unacceptable aesthetic defects in the final product [4]. Hydrophilic coatings increased the risk of fogging, the undesired creeping of the product upward along the inner vial surface [4].
There were workarounds. Adding a surfactant to the formulation suppressed boiling in hydrophobic-coated vials, but it enhanced the formation of bubbles; the bubbling could be eliminated by a degassing step before applying vacuum-induced surface freezing [4]. The combination of degassing and surfactant addition was described as a promising strategy for inducing nucleation by this method in hydrophobic vials [4].
Why freezing is chosen over heat
Among drying methods, freeze-drying is repeatedly the one that preserves appearance and composition. Seven drying methods were compared on Thomson navel orange peel, including sun, shade, oven, vacuum oven, microwave and freeze-drying; drying techniques can degrade heat-sensitive plant metabolites and lead to quality decline [1]. The freeze-dried sample had the highest retention of lightness and yellowness colour values and the lowest browning index, along with the highest essential oil extraction yield of 6.90% and the highest total phenolic content [1]. The conclusion was that freeze-drying was the most efficient approach for preserving both the physical and the essential oil attributes of the peel [1].
Pre-freezing before drying also changed physical quality. In a comparison of drying methods, material pre-frozen in liquid nitrogen and then freeze-dried showed an attractive colour, low shrinkage, a higher rehydration ratio of 2.85 and a soft texture, while hot-air drying caused a collapse of the fibre structure [6]. Rehydration ratio measures how much water the dried material takes back up — a practical proxy for how open the structure left by the ice really is.
What a brand can take from this
Three decisions sit inside the freezing step, and each has a visible consequence.
- Freezing speed. Fast freezing gave lamellar structures with low resistance to vapour escape; slow freezing gave tortuous ones with high resistance [3]. Freezing also made pores larger in silk fibroin hydrogels without changing their chemistry [2].
- The container. Mould gas permeability critically altered pore size and spatial pore distribution [5], and vial inner coatings decided whether a controlled nucleation step ended in boiling, blow-up or fogging [4].
- Fill and shelf temperature. Cooling and freezing periods increased with volume and decreased as the shelf grew colder [7].
A useful question to ask about any freeze-dried cosmetic cake is not only what went into the liquid, but how the ice in it was formed and monitored. Freezing can be tracked in real time rather than assumed: ultrasonic measurement resolved the water-in point, the freezing point and the final phase change [7]. Where the structure itself is the point, freezing can be made directional to produce an ordered layered architecture [8]. The cake's pores, its appearance and how readily it takes water back up are all set before any water has left the vial.
References
- Farahmandfar R, Tirgarian B, Dehghan B, Nemati A. Changes in chemical composition and biological activity of essential oil from Thomson navel orange ( Citrus sinensis L. Osbeck) peel under freezing, convective, vacuum, and microwave drying methods — Food science & nutrition, 2019-12-04.
- Ribeiro M, de Moraes MA, Beppu MM, Monteiro FJ, Ferraz MP. The role of dialysis and freezing on structural conformation, thermal properties and morphology of silk fibroin hydrogels — Biomatter, 2014-03-19.
- Lammens J, Goudarzi NM, Leys L, Nuytten G, Van Bockstal PJ, Vervaet C, Boone MN, De Beer T. Spin Freezing and Its Impact on Pore Size, Tortuosity and Solid State — Pharmaceutics, 2021-12-09.
- Regis F, Arsiccio A, Bourlès E, Scutellà B, Pisano R. Surface Treatment of Glass Vials for Lyophilization: Implications for Vacuum-Induced Surface Freezing — Pharmaceutics, 2021-10-22.
- Han X, Honda Y, Tanaka T, Imura K, Hashimoto Y, Yoshikawa K, Yamamoto K. Gas Permeability of Mold during Freezing Process Alters the Pore Distribution of Gelatin Sponge and Its Bone-Forming Ability — Materials (Basel, Switzerland), 2020-10-22.
- Dong H, Chen J, Li Y, Wang C, Jiao C, Wang L. Influence of Liquid Nitrogen Pre-Freezing and Drying Methods on the Collagen Content, Physical Properties, and Flavor of Fish Swim Bladder — Foods (Basel, Switzerland), 2024-09-01.
- Tseng YH, Cheng CC, Cheng HP, Lee D. Novel real-time diagnosis of the freezing process using an ultrasonic transducer — Sensors (Basel, Switzerland), 2015-05-04.
- Gao P, Wang Y, Li Y, Ding B, Guo J, Yuan Y, Xu Z, Zhang D, Li L, Wang X, Zhang C, Teng C. Directional Freezing Fabrication of RSF/PVA/MXene Aerogels: Layered Structure and High-Efficiency Electromagnetic Interference Shielding — Materials (Basel, Switzerland), 2026-08-21.