Freeze-Drying Plant Extracts: What the Carrier and the Cold Decide
A plant extract leaves the extraction vessel as a liquid. Before it can become a powder in a vial, the water has to go. How the water is removed decides three things a brand will later care about: how much of the extract's original chemistry survives, how dry the finished powder really is, and what the particles look like under a microscope.
Freeze-drying removes water from a frozen liquid at low temperature. Published comparisons against hot-air and spray methods give a consistent picture of what that buys you — and where the real decisions sit.
Drying method changes what survives
Several groups have run the same extract through more than one dryer and measured what came out the other side.
Working with lemon by-product aqueous extracts, researchers compared freeze-drying and spray-drying across three coating agents and measured total phenolic content, total flavonoid content, and ferric ion reducing antioxidant power — three standard laboratory readings of how much of the extract's active chemistry remains [1]. Freeze-drying with a mixture of maltodextrin and soybean protein gave the highest retention on all three readings: 1.66 ± 0.02 mg GAE/g dry basis for phenolics, 0.43 ± 0.02 mg CE/g for flavonoids, and 3.70 ± 0.05 mM TE/g for the reducing power assay [1].
A later study on phenolic compounds extracted from cornsilk compared freeze-drying, spray-drying and microwave-drying, all using maltodextrin as the wall material — the carrier that forms the shell around the extract [2]. The antioxidant results showed freeze-drying was more efficient than the other two, and the highest recovery of phenolic compounds came from freeze-drying [2]. Microstructure, differential scanning calorimetry and infrared data all pointed the same way, and the authors reported that the physical properties of the microparticles changed greatly with the drying technique [2].
Hot air is not always worse on every measure. A study of a wild berry compared freeze-drying at −40 °C with air-drying at 60 °C and 90 °C [3]. The sample air-dried at 90 °C recorded the higher total polyphenol content (2.638 mg GAE/g dry solids), while the freeze-dried sample recorded the higher total flavonoid content (0.395 mg CE/g dry solids) [3]. Compared against the air-dried samples overall, the freeze-dried berries retained a high polyphenol content [3]. The lesson is not that one method always wins, but that each compound class responds differently, and a brand should ask which reading its formula is actually built around.
Moisture and water activity: the numbers that matter in storage
The clearest and most practical difference reported is dryness. In the lemon by-product work, freeze-drying produced microparticles with lower moisture content and lower water activity than spray-drying [1]. Freeze-dried moisture content ranged from 1.15% to 2.15% with a water activity of 0.13 to 0.14; the spray-dried equivalents ran 6.06% to 6.60% moisture and 0.33 to 0.40 water activity [1].
Water activity is a measure of how freely available the remaining water is, as distinct from how much of it there is. Those two sets of numbers are far apart, and they belong to the same extract dried two different ways.
Dryness at the moment of packing is only half the story. Polyphenol storage stability of freeze-dried wild berries was tracked at storage temperatures of 90, 70, 60, 40, 20 and −20 °C, and showed two phases: an initial release phase, then a decay phase [3]. The stability was described using the Peleg model, with the kinetic parameters correlated to storage temperature [3]. A powder is not static on the shelf, and the temperature it is kept at feeds directly into how fast it changes.
The carrier does much of the work
The dryer gets the attention; the carrier often decides the outcome.
In the lemon by-product study, the three maltodextrin-based coatings did not behave alike. Freeze-drying generally produced microparticles with amorphous glassy shapes, but the maltodextrin plus soybean protein mixture formed spherical porous particles instead [1]. Spray-drying, by contrast, produced spherical particles of varying size whatever the coating [1]. X-ray diffraction found a low degree of crystallinity for samples from both techniques [1].
Work on grape pomace extract looked at freeze-drying encapsulation with sodium alginate on its own and in combination with gum Arabic or gelatin [4]. Adding a second coating to the alginate improved encapsulation efficiency, and the alginate–gelatin pair reached 97.02–98.30% [4]. Release of phenolics followed Fick's law of diffusion, and the Korsmeyer–Peppas model fitted the experimental data best [4]. In other words, the coating does not just hold the extract — it governs how it comes back out.
Carriers are also substitutable. extract powders used maltodextrin and inulin as carriers across spray drying and freeze drying [6]. Phenolics in the powders from both drying techniques ranged from 73.2 mg to 78.5 mg per gram of dry matter [6]. Inulin proved as effective as maltodextrin in spray drying, and the authors reported it was an equally efficient carrier in terms of production-process parameters such as moisture content and water activity [6].
What happens before the dryer
Two further studies are a reminder that freeze-drying inherits whatever the earlier steps hand it.
In a comparison of extraction techniques for green pepper oleoresin, the combined ultrasound–microwave method gave the best yield, while the extract from simple maceration had the highest total phenolic content and the highest antioxidant activity [5]. A high positive correlation was found between antioxidant activity and total phenolic content across the methods [5]. The extraction route, not the dryer, set that difference.
Pretreatment matters too. Steaming, blanching and microwave pretreatment were tested on lily bulbs before freeze-drying, and were found to affect the retention, degradation and transformation of polyphenols [7]. Blanching for six minutes gave the highest antioxidant activity of the freeze-dried material, 4.39 ± 0.32 μmol TE/g dry weight, nearly 25.39% above the untreated freeze-dried control [7]. Appropriate steaming and blanching also kept colour close to the untreated freeze-dried product, with the maximum L* value reduced by only 7.57% and 0.55% respectively [7].
Finally, freeze-dried extract is itself an ingredient that changes a base. Freeze-dried mullein flower extract added to cold-pressed oils increased their oxidative stability, but the useful dose depended on the oil: best stability came at 60 mg extract per kg for rapeseed and linseed oil, and at 20 and 15 mg/kg for chia seed and hemp oil respectively [8]. The extract raised the activation energy and lowered the oxidation rate constant [8]. The authors state plainly that the addition should be selected experimentally [8].
What a brand can take from this
Three questions are worth putting to whoever makes your powder. First, what moisture content and water activity does the finished cake actually measure — published freeze-dried figures sit near 1–2% moisture and 0.13–0.14 water activity, well below the spray-dried comparison [1]. Second, which carrier is being used, and why: coating choice changed particle shape, encapsulation efficiency and release behaviour in these studies, and in one case inulin matched maltodextrin outright [1][4][6]. Third, what happens before the dryer — extraction route and thermal pretreatment both altered the phenolic content that freeze-drying then preserved [5][7]. The cold step cannot recover what an earlier step removed.
References
- Papoutsis K, Golding JB, Vuong Q, Pristijono P, Stathopoulos CE, Scarlett CJ, Bowyer M. Encapsulation of Citrus By-Product Extracts by Spray-Drying and Freeze-Drying Using Combinations of Maltodextrin with Soybean Protein and ι-Carrageenan — Foods (Basel, Switzerland), 2018-07-19.
- Pashazadeh H, Zannou O, Ghellam M, Koca I, Galanakis CM, Aldawoud TMS. Optimization and Encapsulation of Phenolic Compounds Extracted from Maize Waste by Freeze-Drying, Spray-Drying, and Microwave-Drying Using Maltodextrin — Foods (Basel, Switzerland), 2021-06-16.
- Al Hasani S, Al-Attabi Z, Waly M, Al-Habsi N, Al-Subhi L, Shafiur Rahman M. Polyphenol and Flavonoid Stability of Wild Blueberry ( Sideroxylon mascatense ) during Air- and Freeze-Drying and Storage Stability as a Function of Temperature — Foods (Basel, Switzerland), 2023-02-17.
- Martinović J, Ambrus R, Planinić M, Šelo G, Klarić AM, Perković G, Bucić-Kojić A. Microencapsulation of Grape Pomace Extracts with Alginate-Based Coatings by Freeze-Drying: Release Kinetics and In Vitro Bioaccessibility Assessment of Phenolic Compounds — Gels (Basel, Switzerland), 2024-05-21.
- Zhang C, Gu F, Hu W, Wu G, Chen W, Dong C, Niu Z. Effect of extraction technique on chemical compositions and antioxidant activities of freeze-dried green pepper — Frontiers in nutrition, 2022-09-02.
- Kucharska-Guzik A, Guzik Ł, Charzyńska A, Michalska-Ciechanowska A. Influence of Freeze Drying and Spray Drying on the Physical and Chemical Properties of Powders from <i>Cistus creticus</i> L. Extract — Foods (Basel, Switzerland), 2025-03-01.
- Cai Y, Quan H, Liu Y, Han X, Lu Y, Lan X, Guo X. The impact of thermal pretreatment on phytochemical profiles and bioactivity of freeze-dried lily bulbs ( Lilium lancifolium ) — Food chemistry: X, 2024-03-15.
- Symoniuk E, Marczak Z, Brzezińska R, Janowicz M, Ksibi N. Effect of the Freeze-Dried Mullein Flower Extract ( Verbascum nigrum L.) Addition on Oxidative Stability and Antioxidant Activity of Selected Cold-Pressed Oils — Foods (Basel, Switzerland), 2023-06-16.