Freezing, Primary Drying, Secondary Drying: What Each Stage Decides
A freeze-dried powder is made by freezing a liquid and then removing the water without ever letting it melt back into liquid. The process is carried out in three steps: freezing, primary drying and secondary drying [1]. Each step is set separately, and each one leaves its mark on the finished cake in the bottle.
The reason to use the method at all is that it is gentle. Freeze-drying is described as a gentle drying technique for high-value products, used because it dries them without damaging product quality [2]. The cost of that gentleness is time and money: the same work describes freeze-drying as very time- and cost-intensive [2]. Almost every decision in cycle design is a trade between those two facts.
Step one: freezing, which builds the structure
Freezing is not simply "making it cold". It is the step that creates the internal structure the rest of the cycle has to work through. Freeze-drying experiments on maltodextrin and sucrose solutions produced different microstructures purely by changing freezing parameters — two different cooling rates and two solid concentrations, 0.05 and 0.15 w/w [2].
What changes is the pore network left behind when ice crystals are later removed. Larger pores are known to shorten primary drying, because vapour moves out more easily [2]. But pore size is not the only thing that matters. In that study, two-dimensional images were recorded throughout drying and in the dry state, and analysed for the movement of the sublimation front and for pore size, orientation and shape [2]. For pores with a high aspect ratio — long, narrow pores — the orientation of the pore mattered more to drying speed than its size; for pores with a lower aspect ratio, pore size was the deciding parameter [2].
Step two: primary drying, where the ice sublimes away
In primary drying, frozen water leaves the product directly as vapour. Three simple heat- and mass-transfer primary drying models were tested, and their predictions of product temperature and sublimation time agreed well with each other [1]. The models were validated against experimental data and then used to tabulate primary drying conditions for common formulations, both amorphous and partially crystalline [1].
That distinction — amorphous versus crystalline — runs through the whole of process design. The review's recommendations for selecting freeze-drying conditions are based on the physical-chemical properties of the formulation together with engineering considerations [1], and it gives worked examples of calculated drying cycles, covering all steps, for typical amorphous and crystalline formulations [1].
Models describe the average. Direct observation shows how messy the reality is. An infrared camera mounted on the chamber roof of a process-scale freeze dryer was used to watch a sucrose/mannitol solution, 4:1 % m/m, dry inside custom cuvettes [3]. One side of each cuvette carried a germanium window next to a mirror set at 45°, so the camera could see both the surface and the full depth of the material [3]. Images were taken every 60 seconds from −40 °C to 30 °C, at a resolution of 2 × 2 mm per infrared pixel, for 45 hours — 2,700 thermograms in all [3].
What they showed is that the formulation, which began as a true solution, dries irregularly, and that the sublimation front does not move evenly through the material [3]. The resolution was enough to reveal lower temperatures deeper down in the material as sublimation progressed [3]. In other words, different parts of the same small volume are at different stages at the same moment.
Step three: secondary drying, which removes what is left
Once the ice is gone, water still remains bound within the solid. In the infrared work, the thermal and spatial resolution was high enough to detect possible evaporative cooling of the upper layers during secondary drying [3] — a reminder that the material is still losing water, and still changing temperature, after the dramatic part of the cycle is over.
Secondary drying is also where shelf temperature is a direct lever on the result. In a study of ultrasonic spray freeze drying, plate temperature for secondary drying was one of three process parameters varied and optimised, at 25, 35 and 45 °C, alongside nozzle frequency (48 and 120 kHz) and flow rate (2, 5 and 8 mL/min) [4]. The optimum combination found was a flow rate of 3.10 mL/min, a plate temperature of 45 °C and a nozzle frequency of 120 kHz [4]. Powders produced that way reached moisture values of 2.92–4.36 % after 8 hours of drying [4]. Examined under magnification, the particles made under the optimum conditions were spherical with pores on their surfaces, and their flow properties were rated as fair under most conditions by the Carr index [4].
What a brand can take from this
Three things follow for anyone specifying how a freeze-dried powder should be made.
- Cycle length can be estimated before the first batch. Models exist for predicting the duration of each segment and the product temperature during primary drying, validated against experimental data and tabulated for common formulation types [1].
- Residual moisture and powder flow are outcomes of the last step. Secondary drying temperature was one of the parameters optimised in the spray freeze drying study, which reported final moisture of 2.92–4.36 % and fair flow behaviour [4].
The 2023 review revisited advice from a 2004 paper on selecting freeze-drying process conditions and concluded that most of those recommendations still apply, with the main advances being ice nucleation control and computer modelling across all steps [1]. The authors also built a database for primary drying and published example cycle designs, intended as a quick way to estimate the design space [1]. A cycle, in short, is something that can be reasoned about in advance — and then checked, because as the imaging work shows, the inside of the cake does not dry as tidily as a model suggests [3].
References
- Tchessalov S, Maglio V, Kazarin P, Alexeenko A, Bhatnagar B, Sahni E, Shalaev E. Practical Advice on Scientific Design of Freeze-Drying Process: 2023 Update — Pharmaceutical research, 2023-10-02.
- Gruber S, Thomik M, Vorhauer-Huget N, Hans L, Tsotsas E, Foerst P. The Influence of Local Microstructure Inhomogeneities on Local Drying Kinetics during Freeze-Drying — Pharmaceutics, 2022-10-07.
- Emteborg H, Charoud-Got J, Seghers J. Infrared Thermography for Monitoring of Freeze Drying Processes-Part 2: Monitoring of Temperature on the Surface and Vertically in Cuvettes during Freeze Drying of a Pharmaceutical Formulation — Pharmaceutics, 2022-05-07.
- Isleroglu H, Turker I. Evaluation of Process Conditions for Ultrasonic Spray Freeze Drying of Transglutaminase — Food technology and biotechnology, 2020-03-01.